A question about a hadith

منصة اسوار المعرفة

العربية english francais русский Deutsch فارسى اندونيسي اردو

Navigate to

About the Sheikh

Fatwas / Hadith and its sciences / A question about a hadith

Views:2336

- Aa +

Question

Dear respected Shaykh, assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. What is the authenticity of the following hadith “Your fasting , slaughtering (on Eid al-Adha) and the beginning of the lunar year should be one day?” سؤال عن حديث

Answer

Praise be to Allah, and may Allah’s peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family and his companions. Wa alaikum assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. As to what follows: In response to your question, we say: This is not the wording of the famous hadith. The wording is, “The day of your fasting is the day of your slaughtering”. Another narration states, “and the day of your new year”. This hadith has no basis as was stated by Imam Ahmad and others. Thus it is not authentic that the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said that.

Praise be to Allah, and may Allah’s peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family and his companions. Wa alaikum assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. As to what follows: In response to your question, we say: This is not the wording of the famous hadith. The wording is, “The day of your fasting is the day of your slaughtering”. Another narration states, “and the day of your new year”. This hadith has no basis as was stated by Imam Ahmad and others. Thus it is not authentic that the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said that.

Previous topic

Grading a hadith as weak is not an issue for which a person with an opposing should b

Next

Us saying to Ahl al-Kitab (People of the Book), “Our brothers.”

New Subjects

1. Should the mus'haf be left in the hand of a kafir?

2. The issue of a delayed sale involving gold and silver where rulings of interest are applicable.

3. Ruling on selling what is intended to be used for prohibited things.

4. Uncertainty with maintenance and servicing contracts.

5. Is this method of marketing prohibited?

6. Ruling on working in a beauty parlour.

7. An employee deceiving his sponsor.

8. What is the ruling on paying blood money through insurance?

9. Knocking off at work before time.

10. Ruling on buying the whole sacrifice

11. Ruling on selling razor blades.

12. Does this necessity permit interest?

13. Ruling on salary and overtime wages of a university lecturer.

14. My wife works at a massage spar.

15. Ruling on using copied discs.

most viewed

1. What is the ruling of using eye drops in Ramadan? ( Views 10446 )

2. Enjoying the buttocks of the wife ( Views 10098 )

3. The signs of Laylatul Qadr ( Views 8515 )

4. Intercourse with the wife in the bathroom ( Views 5765 )

5. Recitation of surah Fatiha by a person standing behind an Imam in a prayer that is read loudly. ( Views 5744 )

6. What is meant by the clear verses (muhkamat) and unclear verses (mutashabihat). ( Views 5537 )

7. The time of the Friday ghusl (bath) ( Views 5421 )

8. Taking loans to perform Hajj ( Views 5410 )

9. The purported hadith that ‘Aisha breastfed an adult with the Prophet’s permission ( Views 5322 )

10. The ruling of intentional or unintentional ejaculation during the day in Ramadan ( Views 5293 )

11. Time for reading surah Al-Kahf ( Views 5282 )

12. The ruling on seeking the help of Muslim jinns ( Views 5272 )

13. Is it Sunnah to keep long hair? ( Views 5230 )

14. A small amount of gold in men’s clothing ( Views 5209 )

15. Explanation of Kaf-Ha-Ya-Ain-Swad ( Views 5023 )

related topics

1. The examination of the hadith which states, “Speaking in the mosque eats up good deed

2. The hadeeth: “The Prophet (peace be upon him) prohibited that a man should wear sanda

3. Using ‘Umar’s statement as justification for rejecting authentic hadiths

4. Issues in the science of the defects of hadith

5. The authenticity of the hadith: “Whoever does not perform the witr payer is not one

6. Zakat on money that is used as a guarantee

7. The purported hadith that ‘Aisha breastfed an adult with the Prophet’s permission

8. The meaning of the hadith “There is no evil omen except in three things.”

9. Sixteen issues in the science of hadeeth

10. Reconciling between the hadith: “There is no infection and no evil omen” and the hadi

you may like

1. Us saying to Ahl al-Kitab (People of the Book), “Our brothers.”

2. Five questions concerning Allah’s Names and Attributes

3. The ruling on saying, “Help, O Messenger of Allah!”

4. Swearing by other than Allah contradicts Tawhid al-Uluhiyyah (worship)

5. Those who aid the disbelievers in their war against Muslims

6. Attributing Allah’s fingers to His hand

7. The ruling on us saying, “May Allah not have decreed it.”

8. Is man upon a path of determinism or free-will?

9. Do the angels descend in a gathering that contains images?

10. The statement, “If the days have betrayed our covenants”

Viewed Topics

1.

Comments